Reviews

Everyone's a critic, but we've been doing it longer.

Gears of War: E-Day review

The hole shooting match

In a box somewhere, I have a polaroid of Cliff Bleszinski pretending to chainsaw off my head. It's a memento from a trip to Epic Games which I'd won in a fan-art competition by drawing a giant frog-monster. This trip, and the early hands-on I had with the very first Gears of War, formed the basis of a preview that turned into a 20-year-long incarceration within the games industry. I wouldn't say this makes me a superfan, but I can't help but look at E-Day—a prequel to or perhaps a tentative reboot of a series that so neatly maps onto what I unconvincingly call my career—with a mixture of rare nostalgia and crushing mortal dread. If only I could be rebooted too.

At least I can now get answers to the many questions that have tormented my every moment since 2006: How did hardbitten jarhead protagonist Marcus Fenix get that scar on his ultra-wide chin? Which Archimedean genius invented the chainsaw-gun? And, primarily, what were the events of "Emergence Day", when the Locust—a league of hideous subterranean creatures—first popped out of their burrows to wreak planetwide horror upon humanity? If these were questions that you had never really been tempted to ask, then no matter: this game serves as both a fresh introduction and the most potent distillation of its cover-shooter core to date. So pure indeed, that E-Day does not believe it needs any other sort of distraction across the course of its 20 hour-long campaign. To the combat designers' credit, it's almost true.

Amid the ubiquity of cover-shooters that followed Gears' release, and because of the game's own wilfully obnoxious, frattish tone, it's easy to forget or overlook what made—and now makes again—Gears' tactical combat so clever, taut and tactile. Beneath the gleeful head-stomping, chainsaw-revving bloodshed is a game about quick thinking, positioning and coordination, with players forced to adapt their defensive formation to counter the increasing pressure and changing threat of their foe; or to break an intractable deadlock with suppression, distraction and flanking.

This post is for subscribers only (it's free!)

Already have an account? Sign in.

Thousand Hells review

Other hell is people

As readers in the UK will know, there are many hells, and you can and should put together a team to rob powerful figures within them. And such a team would of course be not a spreadsheet of optimal (ugh) builds, but a guessing game of hedged bets and approximate ideas.

Thousand Hells has you lead this team on a journey, first to reach hell at all, then to find and retrieve something, or get agonisingly close before making one too many mistakes and losing everything. But this isn't the arbitrary, timewasting death of the roguelike. This is just that story. It can be dissatisfying, and parts of it can not really make sense. This is at times its big flaw, and at others, where it feels most successful. Are we still saying "same"?


Each game is an adventurous journey followed by a heist, then a shorter but still fraught journey back. Each is also a named plot with a specific target, and could take you to one of four hells (the "thousand" are scene-setting) this time. It's also a new team, including you, the leader.

Handpainted style picture of a settlement set underground, brightly painted. A minigame plays out on the right, with tokens and gamey bits. Text describes the party saying "I'm sorry, friend ghoul, but we don't know the entry toll." The ghoul: "You call me friend? No one ever calls me that." Party: "As travelers in an unfamiliar city we extend friendship to all." Ghoul: "In that case, you may pass, and I forgive you for failing to bring me any sweet, delicious corpse flesh."
This caption is a formal request for Tunnel Ghoul fan art

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy review

Magical mystery minotaur

On a certain kind of dull, wet day, my dull, wet brain craves a particular sort of comfort: to burrow into the plush, numbing blanket of a middle-to-lowbrow thirdperson action-adventure. Blockbuster brawling, a light bit of puzzling, and an enviably sunny island idyll backdrop is all I ask. A little bit Uncharted, largely unchallenging and entirely unrepentant.

From a cursory glance at the trailers, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy presented as exactly this—at least to a fool, such as myself, who had not at that point played the previous, enthusiastically grim Plague Tale games, to which Resonance is a prequel. It is also a departure from their relentless filth and pestilence: a breezier action spectacle that hews closer to mainstream conformity, composed of the popcorn action-adventure staples I crave. There is brawling, puzzling and, yes, a stunning island idyll to explore. But then, just under half-way in, it abruptly decides it isn't content to coast on genre expectations and introduces a novel and horrifying element, a bit of systems-first enemy design that is so unguessably strange that I can't bring myself to spoil it in this review.

This post is for paying subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.

Ace Combat 8: Wings Of Theve review

Fight or flight response

If Ace Combat 7 lacked anything (and I don't think it did) you might say it was a feeling of getting close to your wingmates. Project Aces think so anyway. Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve repeatedly plonks you right on the deck of its aircraft carrier homebase, in first-person perspective and proximate enough to reach out and touch your squadpal's perfectly rendered stubble. You cannot get much closer than this. But there is a sense of overcompensation. Mission by mission this passive in-flight entertainment takes over and the player gets fewer displays of spectacular air buffoonery of their own. 

Luckily, the story is continuously stupid in the refreshing way Ace Combat can be. I don't think this new jetshootser is as airtight as the previous game in the series. There is, frankly, a lot of filler. You find yourself going through the motions of popping ground targets until the next lengthy story beat can hit. But when it's good, it remains an explosive cavalcade of implausibilities that makes me laugh. For Ace Combat, that's enough.

You play as a silent pilot known to the world as "Wings". But only because you've inherited this nickname, Dread Pirate Roberts style, from a pilot you knew for less than a day. To top it off, you now hear his lyrical inner monologue inside your own head for the whole game. It's an off-beat choice that, at first, reminded me of the dead narrator in Sunset Blvd, but was cheapened as soon as the voice drew attention to the conceit ("So you can hear me?" he says. "This is weird for me too."). But that's videogames in general and Ace Combat games in particular. They like to spell things out in big letters written in smoke in the sky. 

Three crewmates chat over trays of food in a ship's canteen.
Between the voice in your head, the canteen chats, and the rock musicians, it feels like the narrative designers have been playing a lot of Cyberpunk 2077.

The series' characteristically farfetched storytelling - a head-on collision of sincere cultural observation and comically militant absurdity - is standing to attention throughout. Once again, it's WAR. The best interpretation of these rocketing jet 'em ups I've read is that they belong to the mecha genre. They are theatrical in a disarming way that'll win over anyone willing to accept a world where convicted felons are allowed to fly MIG-29s to atone for their crimes, where global wars with millions of casualties happen every 10 years but where there's still enough optimism to build space elevators and gleaming futuristic cities just in time for the next weapon of mass destruction to be invented. There are interesting themes in Ace Combat games - they are delivered with the subtlety of a cruise missile.

The player fires missiles from a cockpit view, hitting a large airship.
This airship has a 1km wingspan. It deserves to be shot down for its hubris alone.

As for what it's actually like to fly: yup, feels good. You airbrake hard into high gravity turns, launch special air-to-air ordinance, pop flares when a missile is locked onto you, and chase bad guys through drippy clouds when your homing reticule is interrupted by beautifully composed sky mist. I miss the thunderstorms of its predecessor but its possible I just didn't fly through the right bits of dark heaven.

Some of the most tense air battles can involve a ferocious amount of airwave chatter. Fighter squadrons, ground troops, commanding officers, and enemy trashtalkers compete for your focus at a clattering pace. In these missions, the feeling can be one of chaotic overwhelm. You are flying through an aural storm of in my sightses, on your sixes, and bombs awayses, with both friendlies and rivals blasting music over the comms. Among all this staticky crosstalk you have to listen for mission critical information - who to shoot and when to get 'em shot by. It's as much an exercise in concentration as a test of your piloting skills.

You kit out your jet accordingly. A mission with lots of ground targets? Stuff your steel belly full o' bombs. Anticipate a dogfight with some nippy aces? Pick something fast and stock up on missiles with special guidance abilities. As ever, you earn points in each mission to spend on new planes and parts. You'll fit gadgets to make your missiles lock-on faster, or reload quicker, or grant extra space to carry more ordnance. Later you can unlock some green-flavoured support planes that you'll fob off on your comrades because their special electronic warfare gizmos buff your own missile lock capabilities.  

With 30 missions in total, they were destined to be hit and miss. Highlights include flying under the struts of a floating island and blasting the support pillars as you glide past. Or dodging huge glowing bursts of railgun fire from land battleships that have burrowed in among innocent skyscrapers, like a cat at the back of a cupboard filled with delicate glassware. 

But there are an equal amount of shrugfests and simple "kill everything" missions set against a timer. One mission sees you and a pilot buddy crashing in enemy turf - a South American coded country full of resistance fighters. Your escape sees you stealth-flying through green blobs of radar in an rickety old plane at agonisingly slow pace while the stakes are melodramatised to you via dialogue on the radio. Aside from being a repeat of Ace Combat 7's most annoying mission, there is almost zero tension. You're just gliding gently to the exit while everyone says: "Oh no!" On the other hand, this is also where the story throttles up to perilously high levels of glamourous idiocy.

The village you crash near just happens to be visited by the most important General of the enemy air force - a futuristic wheelchair-bound woman of deadpan villainry. The first-person sequence that follows is a kind of Inglorious Basterds style dinner scene with four ace pilots squinting at each other (your head is on a swivel during these sequences, so you can look around, but not do much more). The villainess is served tea and, instead of extending her good arm to take the teacup, a robot arm rises from beneath the table and passes the cup to her working hand. It is a hilarious and needless flex of robotics.

A general in a white uniform sits in her wheelchair and speaks to a villager, saying she will strike some ne'er-do-wells with "guided munitions if necessary".
The General notices a villager has been hurt by soldiers and shows her sympathetic side... by promising to launch a missile at the culprits.

This character is not alone in her animeness. Many others feel like the result of a brainstorming session taken to hard-drinking extremes. What if there was a pacifist ghost? What if a famous rock band could pilot F-16s? What if the General was a nomadic tribal heiress? What if the British air traffic guy was called "Dealer" and spoke entirely in gambling metaphors? What if there were a bunch of pilots who hid underground until they went crazy from being deprived of flying for too long? 

This post is for paying subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.

Ostranauts review

Everything can be salvaged, but make it a curse

"Ostranauts, Graham, is I think a very Jank-y kind of game", I said, very differently to that and before I needed to fit it into an intro. This came from dabbling with much earlier versions, and from knowing that Graham loved Neo Scavenger, Blue Bottle Games's earlier survival game about undignified scrabbling and lusting after carrier bags. And that Brendy is a space boy, and Jonty touches cars. Throw in my love of salvage and you get a game about bumbling around space in a ship assembled by hand, one reclaimed component at a time. You get Ostranauts.

You also get lowercase jank. Lots of it. "Bordering on a professional dilemma" kind of jank. There is so much going wrong with this game that I'm unsure if this will be a recommendation or an SOS.

Ship control panel, with many modules, some with chunky switches, one showing a wireframe map as my ship narrowly zooms between two other ships
Incoming transmission, sir! It says "neeeeeooooooww".

It is a project game. I have a goal, and I see other possibilities on the way to meeting that goal. Some of those are incorporated into the project, others distract me and become the day's entertainment before I try again tomorrow. Others still become another project and oh my god what day is it. What year?

This post is for paying subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.

Sprawl Zero review

Well executed

You cannot reload in Sprawl Zero. Instead, you mindwarp a fallen gun straight to your hand, unload all the bullets into a cyborg guard, then javelin the hollowed weapon at his colleague's skull. You then brainsnatch that victim's rifle into your fingers while it's still falling from his dead hands, and you do it all again. 

For the first half hour of this retro blastathon, I habitually hammered the R key after loosing a few bullets. It did nothing. Body memory will not help you here, even if your head memory is summoning visions of the 2000s sci-fi shooters this dusty megacity is inspired by. You will navigate blocky levels full of secrets while lobbing empty pistols into the faces of your enemies and tossing back grenades. The gag presents itself. This is literally a throwback shooter. 

You are a cybernetic killfiend of the Junta, the city's ruling force. A terrorist group are doing terrorism, and worse! They're being preachy about it. It's your job to bleed 'em out and silence their cultish leader, Silas. I say "your job" but it's clear from the protagonist's robotic recitations ("Memory is the phantom. Autonomy is the flaw.") that you are a pre-programmed, captive killing instrument doing the dirty work of your shadowy, fash overseers. Not that your cult foes are clean-cut goodies. Better just keep murdering until the plot twists happen.

It is technically a prequel to a wall-running FPS called Sprawl from a few years ago. I sensed a few nods to that story but they have gone completely over my head.

Yes, 2000s shooters may be the soul, but the body is all Doom 2016. It is a rhythmic, flowing shooter that demands the player keep pace. Enemies are nippy and move around arenas with cowardly self-preservation, making movement more important than cover. The combat rhythm is a dance on repeat: pick up, shoot, punch, dash - not forgetting to use your abilities to mix things up. You telepathically pluck up gas cannisters and chuck them at dudes, and you earn your health back by remembering to use bullet-time every so often, which generates glowy green healing drops. 

Most importantly, the lack of ammo forces you to snap up and try out every gun, even those you don't like so much. Dropped weapons are coloured according to rarity, so you can easily teleyoink a rare purple pistol and ignore the everyday grey guns. But sometimes you have to improvise and use whatever's grabbable in a heartbeat. 

I commend this as an act of despotic game design. The developers are forcing you to eat your vegetables because - as it turns out - some vegetables are delicious and you will feel better having digested all your grenade launchers. In 2001 some hardwired troglodytes moaned about Halo only letting you carry two guns at any time, but this was the most interesting change in mainstream shooter design for a decade. Sprawl Zero pushes that logic a little further and builds a whole game around it. It makes one big combat decision and commits. For that alone, it is worth playing.

This post is for subscribers only (it's free!)

Already have an account? Sign in.

The Blood Of Dawnwalker review

Dawn Walker? I thought you said his name was Coen?!

Two weeks ago, the vampire that rules over Coen of Laslea's valley torched his village, captured his family, and cursed Coen to an eternity of blood thirst. This evening, Coen is standing on a mountain pass, getting pelted with rocks by large, jeering goat people. "Baah", they taunt. "Baaah-ha-ha". 

Coen isn't happy about this, but he can't do a thing. This is because I've decided the goat people are my friends, so I keep choosing pacifist dialogue options despite three opportunities - and constant encouragement from my companion - to kill them all.

I'm having one of a handful of asterisk-free excellent times thus far in The Blood Of Dawnwalker. Mostly because the game has finally offered up a crumb of that good, good whimsy after submerging me in fifteen hours of muck, pestilence, viscera, laborious combat, torture, 'excellent artisanal' epic trousers, and despair. 

See that castle? You can go bowling with it.

There are sweetly sombre vistas and scenes of chilling folk horror lurking in this cursed valley; awe and terror dancing around the maypole together. There are fascinating hints at a history of forbidden magic, and uncomfortably tangible tales of oppression tolerated through paralysing fear of the alternative. Before Brencis came, cruel boyars ran unchecked, and the black death ran rife. Now, every week at mass, his vampire court drink from the people, and share their blood in return. The plague is gone. The boyars were hanged. Newborns are the "strongest they've ever been". Vampire tyranny is one thing, but vampire populism? What a hook.

There is all that, plus some of the best violin scraping and the absolute best gnarled bog trees ever committed to Unreal Engine. But there's also such constant, droning misery and aimless sadism-as-set-dressing that Dawnwalker often devolves into a four Yorkshireman-esque pissing contest with itself. "It smells of rot and blood here," Coen groans as he enters a cave. Yes, Coen. I know, I know. It's rot and blood all the way down. 

This post is for subscribers only (it's free!)

Already have an account? Sign in.

Vholume review

Who runs this city?

A good parkour game is a gauntlet of faith. You follow the flow of a city designed by some invisible hand: paving stones tilted at angles suggestive of a left turn, a warm light inviting you into a distant doorway, some plank of corrugated scrap extended toward an unseen edge. You are chasing a breadcrumb trail, except you don't always know what's crumb and what's dirt. Over and over, you leap without looking. Sometimes that means you die. But, when it's done right, you feel like you are predicting the future mere milliseconds ahead of time. 

The best levels of Vholume make me feel like a clairvoyant with springs for legs. The worst feel like a brief test of my faith, nothing more. The protagonist of this wall-running platformer will often wheeze as if they're running out of breath. At the end of one run, I realised I had been holding my own lungs for the two full minutes it took me to hit the dark doorway that marks the finish line. This game is such a rush, it will deprive you of oxygen. 

Thirty-one levels, a wall run, and a