The cruelly overlooked Stirring Abyss restores dread to a number-sick genre
I never gave Stirring Abyss a fair hearing. Or any hearing, really, which is the same thing when you're a critic who is personally responsible for the fate of all game creators. A squad-based Lovecraftian tactical RPG wasn't what I was looking for when it came out in 2020, which is both deeply unfair and inevitable in a world where both baklava and lasagne exist, and both must sometimes be craved. Except not with beef, damn you! Arggh.
But it was immediately different to the usual "Firaxcom but with cards or whatever" routine. Some of that distinctiveness is in the list of design details I just deleted for the seventh time, because more importantly, the rest is what its peers lack, and what makes that design work: the dread. The dread, and the doubt.

It's not the doubt of arbitrary chance, but of whether anything you're doing is a good idea. Its classic "unfathomable fathoms" horror narrative has familiar signs of how grave the situation really is, while still being a little unclear exactly which way things will go. And that leaves you always worried there's a terrible surprise at the edge of its oppressive darkness.
This post is for paying subscribers only