Jank Mail: Stolen valour
The most important news of the week is that we’re running a sale. From now until the end of the month, you can get 20% off an annual subscription using the code GRUDGING, which you can access right here; a paid sub gets you access to all our subscriber-exclusive articles and podcasts, which are helpfully summarised here.
The lesser news was the release of The Game, which is already the biggest entertainment launch of all time, but is not yet available on PC so we get to act like we’re above it all. Join us next week when we get to act the same about Black Friday; this is the sort of thing that our cherished paying subscribers enable. In the meantime, we had our first mysterious byline, who is here to complain about the big GTA reviews.
I'm not trying to argue that Grand Theft Auto 6 isn't worthy of its top marks and glowing reviews. I haven't played it yet, so I've no idea. But it's a concern to me that there seems to be so little interrogation of it as a project. Among all its many reviews, not a single person considered it by a criteria that it did not meet? Was there not at least one curmudgeon with a review copy? Did not a single person consider its excesses of scope to be grotesque? No one, sixty hours deep into yet another crime caper, questioned whether their time might have been better spent? I don't care how good a game is, nothing should be met with such unfettered, unanimous praise.
Sin’s column, which we've given up trying to come up with a clever name for, plucked out Stirring Abyss, a tactical RPG from the pandemic times.
I often reject the tainted artifact or sinister deal with a terrible unknown price, especially when it involves subjecting my loyal fighters to cyber surgery, or evil pods. I don't care if it's an "upgrade": I'm not doing that to anyone. Obviously corrupting your stranded submarine boys in Stirring Abyss with the stuff from that mysterious void will forever curse them and possibly doom us all. But this is a Lovecraftian tale, so we're doing it, lads. We have a duty to this ship, and to this story.
For the latest Living in Sim, Brendy was charmed by the ASCII horrors of Ablahshikar without ever really grasping what was happening.
In terms of simulation and flavour, I enjoy this vagueness, the granularity with which you can supposedly affect the moods of your blood-stained sea dogs. There is something extremely Otessa Mossfegh about the writing in these scenes, a kind of messed-up, sci-fi fantasy McGlue, a disgusting delight I never would've predicted I'd see in a game. In terms of making you feel queasy, weird, (aroused?), it is undeniably effective. In terms of a functioning RPG, it's not clear how useful managing the men's emotions actually is. I have no idea what difference it makes to have a crewman with a low or high Panic meter. All I do know these sailors will mutiny at some point, because it happened to me more than once.
For this week’s subscriber-only podcast, Alice and Brendy got together to discuss the fine art of hating, although in a disappointingly reasonable fashion. The Lie-In collected some thoughtful analysis around last week’s debate around AI use in Big Walk, something that already feels like it was a month ago, and enough people liked The Jankword that we have permitted Marsh to make some more.
Outside Jank, GTA was figuratively the only game in town although some plucky souls launched against it, including Australia Did It, Flame, Forest and Flood and Volvy’s Adventure Reslimed, the latter with a shot-for-shot-remake of the GTA trailer. Otherwise every news source were choked with GTA output from Wednesday onwards, reflecting a historical moment of monoculture around the biggest and possibly last of its kind, but I’m not going to summarise all that because (a) boring (b) every algorithmic feed in your life, which is to say every data feed in your life, is cramming GTA into every possible gap and (c) we’re deep into strip-mined spoiler territory which makes the game itself much less fun to play, although once again I must admit that the posts are good.

The title’s much-celebrated quality has been partially attributed to Rockstar’s habit of retaining staff rather than firing them, although we should not overlook that it fired 34 people for being in a union-based Discord server, the tribunal on which proceeded to judgement this week. They did at least mention them in the credits which is rarer than it should be.
In the shadow of the behemoth, Ubisoft saw the GTA release as a great day to bury bad news, which included firing another 166 people and their latest financial results. They also launched a dedicated AI unit, just in time for AI to go from stock-market catnip to stock-market catastrophe, which is pretty much just how this year has been for them.

Firaxis is making a new XCOM game, which is good, but it’s not going very well, which is bad, and we only know this because they laid off a third of their staff, which is worse. Build A Rocket Boy is £61.7m in debt and it’s going to recover that by suing the people who said that MindsEye was bad, which is a big target but perhaps challenging to hit. Xbox and EA are still trying to make in-game ads happen and it might even stick this time because it’s increasingly difficult to make AAA budgets work.
Gabe Newell is notable among superyacht owners for not being a huge asshole although I remain convinced it’s all a trap. Bethesda is supporting the development of Fallout with Cats. The guy who used to run Take-Two says people will come round to using AI in game dev. Unity is giving grant money to game developers.
In the Jank comments, quasiotter appreciated Brendy playing Ablahshikar so they don’t have to:
i award this : Game of the Year That I Will Never Play
kyle_ar was one of many people discussing the implications of AI use following Graham’s collection of links on on House House’s use of AI to finish Big Walk:
I see this as the "radium - it's good for your health" moment for contemporary software dev.
Alligator_bf suggested that the pressures of game reviews means that day-one judgements are never going to be all that interesting:
So while Some Guy Called Chris, Tom or Matt, Probably probably is technically correct, it's not realistic to imagine things could be - or, for a lot of consumer-focussed readers, should be - any different for the release window. If you want deep, cogent, thoughtful analysis of video games, have patience while the real critics cook.
That’s it for this week. Go and play some PC games.
Comments ()