Graham Smith

Graham Smith

Graham is a former editorial director of Rock Paper Shotgun and editor-in-chief of PC Gamer. He has now been a games journalist for over twenty years, and retains a bottomless appetite for playing new games and tinkering with old ones.
Brighton, UK

Sandustry review

A time sink that respects your time

I started Sandustry on a whim at 8:15pm on a Friday evening. I was still playing at 2am. I went to bed, woke up at 9am, and immediately started playing again. It's rare that a game gets its claws into me like this. It's even rarer that I feel good about it.

Sandustry, now in Early Access, is a factory builder with a great hook: every pixel is physically simulated. Think Noita, but instead of a deadly roguelike, you're laying down conveyor belts and sorters to gradually process all the natural resources of an alien world. Factorio but with gravity. Satisfactory but I'm satisfied.

I used to think I had a complicated relationship with 'busywork games', the kind that give you a todo list of simple (and sometimes prima facie tedious) tasks, and invite you to decide whether the experience is a flow or fugue state. I love some of those games (Pokémon Pokopia, Turnip Boy) and flee almost instantly from the seeming pointlessness of others. I now think my relationship is very simple: some todo lists feel worthwhile and others do not, and it's a matter of design as to which is which. In other words, it is the games that are good or bad, not me.

Sand and grey residue moved along a conveyor belt.
This factory was hell but I was proud of it anyway.

Too often factory builders feel like they're putting artificial obstacles in my path and daring me to work hard enough to render the inconveniences moot. That power curve can feel good, but more often than not it feels too much like the bad kind of wasting time. I don't want to cup water for ten hours to earn a bucket.

This post is for subscribers only (it's free!)

Already have an account? Sign in.

The Lie-In

Links worth clicking

Good morning, videogames. I fell hard for a new game on Friday night and I am eager to get back to playing it. Thankfully my links are already all picked out, neatly folded, and arranged in a row below. There are some good ones this week.

For Chisel, Mikhail Klimentov grapples with the thousands of hours he's spent playing Valorant, and paints an unflinchingly honest portrait that will be relatable to those who have ever obsessed over a multiplayer game.

I could feel myself reverting to boyhood, storming out of the proverbial playdate cursing my erstwhile friends after particularly infuriating games. I fell victim to those school-age anxieties – Do these guys even like me? – coming out the back of marathon double-digit-hour gaming sessions, at the end of which everyone is more or less nonverbal. I could feel my neural pathways atrophying with every inside joke repeated unthinkingly, landing to lesser and lesser effect as the night wore on. I grew hypersensitive to small and more than likely imagined changes in social gravity: who’s up, who’s down, who’s spending less time online, who can get people to come online just by getting into the

What you could play this weekend

Plus what we're playing

One thousand games are released on Steam every minute now, but thankfully almost all of them are about tidying up cluttered retail businesses and were made with varying degrees of AI assistance, and thus they can be safely ignored. The three games that remain this week are all spiritual successors to Nintendo 64 classics and I have dutifully listed each of them below.

We've also noted what we personally intend to play this weekend, though we are but lowly serfs kneeling before your own lordly proclamations in the comments below.

Agent 64: Spies Never Die

Splitscreen multiplayer in blocky, square rooms with repeating wall and floor textures.

I have tremendously fond memories of GoldenEye 007 on the N64, although they mostly focus on the multiplayer mode and its custom settings. 'Proximity mines only' on Facility remains an all-timer. Agent 64: Spies Never Die is a straightforward spiritual successor that aims to replicate the feeling of Rare's classic, including a singleplayer campaign, splitscreen multiplayer, and bots to fight against should your friends not want to revisit the past.

Wild Blue Skies

A small single-fighter craft zooms along a valley, through which a river runs, with a city built into the green hills on either side.

It must be rough to spend years working on a StarFox spiritual successor only for Nintendo themselves to swoop in and both announce and release a remake of their

We now have full text RSS for paying subscribers

Stop visiting Jank today

We want you to read Jank, but that doesn't mean we need you to visit our website. There are no adverts here, so your clicks? Worthless to us. You can keep your clicks to yourself, frankly, and the best way to do that is by subscribing to Jank in your RSS reader and enjoying our work from there.

We've always had a full text RSS feed, but when we started slipping certain posts behind the paywall (because we do want your money), those posts became truncated within the feed. Paying members had to click over to the site in order to access the rest of the article. I can't abide that, so we've fixed it. There's now a second full text RSS feed for paying subscribers.

This new RSS feed is behind a URL that is unique to each paying subscriber. If you're signed in and a paying member, it should display in this helpful box:

Loading your private feed…

The Lie-In

Links worth clicking

Good morning, videogames. Last week's Lie-In was written in advance to cover for my absence, and frankly it was rude for people to continue publishing articles while I was away. Now this week's Lie-In needs to somehow contain almost two weeks of links to writing about videogames. Terrible for me; a bumper crop for you.

Aftermath launched Hater Week, a batch of articles in which they got a lot off their chests. I love this idea. Here's Gita Jackson on why survival games are annoying.

A video game character does not need to eat, drink, or sleep. They do not need to take their meds every day. They don’t go to the bathroom, or get hair cuts, or trim their nails—all these tiny chores that take up time in my life that I never think about but must complete. So why, why, would I play a video game where doing all these chores is not only necessary, but the point.

Speaking of haters, academic and translator Emily Wilson discussed her distaste for Christopher Nolan's adaptation of The Odyssey. Wilson published a translation of the Odyssey in 2017 and knows her stuff, at

What you could play this weekend

Plus what we're playing

I am back from my Scottish absence, which means that instead of being prepared a week in advance, this article is being written in real-time. Click on it quick enough and you can see my cursor still scrabbling across the screen, laying out words about three new games you might like to try this coming weekend - and, as a new bonus, adding words from the Jank crew on what we're hoping to divert ourselves with this weekend.

Let us know in the comments, as always, what you're going to be playing.

Sovereign Tower

A golden-haired knight called Gwendan, surrounded by UI elements related to their skills and quests.

I've been reading Tower Dungeon, Tsutomu Nihei's manga which answers the question: what if there was a big tower? This RPG makes you the manager of such a place, with a Round Table of hot knights to send on quests and keep happy. I love the loose lines of the character artwork and UI, and am encouraged by the ability to turn back time (via a demon in the basement) to reverse previous decisions.

Doloc Town

Several platforms, viewed from the side in 2D, covered in plants. The character wears a white coat and welding mask.

If I encountered Doloc Town when it launched in Early Access last year, I forgot about it, but this sidescrolling survival-farming game has now hit

Emuurom review

Wanna get lost?

At its best, Emuurom leads you to make new discoveries several times per minute. You are exploring a world, screen-by-screen, with nothing but a scanner you can point at the flora and fauna. Scan a cloud? It rains. The rain falls on a flower? It blooms. Scan a bird? It flies left to right. Scan a different bird? It shrieks. The shriek touches a flower? It splits into seeds. What do the seeds do? You'll discover that soon enough, with a little playful experimentation, and then discover another thing and another thing. Playing Emuurom is like being parachuted into the middle of Moominland without Tove Jansson's prose to guide you and so each new creature and interaction is yours to piece together.

That's Emuurom's surface layer, and it's a joy. It's where I live. Many people will try to convince you that this puzzle-platformer's greatness lies in the cleverness beneath that surface, however. Its developer has spent eight years constructing layer upon layer of secrets which reveal themselves only via perseverance and effort. Emuurom contains, for example, a unique language to translate. That's the kind of worldbuilding that makes a certain kind of person immediately excited, and it's a transparently impressive act of design. For me, a dummy, such depths are both admirable and off-putting, and so I am here to tell you that Emuurom is something much more than clever. It's fun.

"Another Admin Seal opened? Nice, mjay... because the comet is on the move!" says a character called Ilivesilives.
There's a pronunciation guide for every weird lil' guy's name.

Jumping on things and scanning them are the only modes of interaction here. Emuurom has no combat and your character, sent to this planet like a data upload, has no health bar and cannot die. Instead, the creatures that populate this planet either passively let you shove them around, move along fixed paths, or shove you back when prompted. One area has dolphin-like creatures that leap out of the water when you scan them, for example, so you scan them when they're beneath you and they shove you to a platform that's higher than you can jump.

I'm giving away that discovery for free because Emuurom is full of them, and you will intuit much of what you must do to progress without much conscious thought. The trick is to just keep scanning everything, old or new, and to trust that the game will reveal itself to you, at least until you reach its endgame. These reveals are delivered in part via written descriptions of the creatures and plants you encounter, each of which have names, behaviours, and occasionally short snippets of dialogue. They build up a picture of a world that is playfully alien and silly, when the pixels and puzzles might otherwise have been austere.

This post is for subscribers only (it's free!)

Already have an account? Sign in.

The Lie-In

Links worth clicking

Good morning, videogames. I am still, somehow, on holiday, but once again I have prepared an article for you to read in advance. How have I collected a collection of articles worth reading this week when I haven't been at my desk? Well, no one ever said all the articles had to be new.

Many remember Kieron Gillen's New Games Journalism manifesto. No one remembers what I'd consider its sibling, written months earlier by then-PC Gamer editor Mark Donald. Donald had just redesigned the UK version of the magazine to focus more on games post-release and to support the kind of in-game cultural reporting Gillen later referenced, and he posted an open letter looking for contributions. It's more of a pragmatic appeal for pitches than Kieron's call to arms, but I think it's nevertheless an inspiring mission statement. It was what prompted me to pitch to PC Gamer the following year, after which Mark handed me my first paid commission and, a few months later, a full-time job.

I'm trying to create a magazine that communicates the incredible experiences gamers have. A magazine that reports on the amazing transformations